Three Hearts, One
In the Supernatural fandom, Sam, Dean, and Castiel all love the same woman — and then Arthur Ketch shows up to make it four.
You may also like

My Favorite Secret: JJK College AU
𝓴𝓲𝓻𝓫𝔂 (。•ᴗ•。)
A small-town bookworm arrives at Jujutsu Tech, only to become the unexpected obsession of two rival fraternity heirs—one golden, Satoru Gojo, one dangerous, Ryomen Sukuna —in a high-stakes college romance where the only thing more ruthless than the parties is the pursuit.

Astral University—Minor in Bad Decisions
V_V
You came to university to get a degree. Unfortunately, everyone else came to ruin your life.

Not Your Soulmate
yazz.criss
A Supernatural fanfic where Amara's 'gift' to Dean Winchester is a woman from another dimension bound to him and Sam by fate — and she couldn't care less.

Ink and Ink
savvybar199
She transferred across the country to surprise her boyfriend. She found him with three other girls instead.

Supernatural: Blood on the Highway
AnnaWilliams
Join the Winchester brothers on the road, hunting demons, ghosts, and things that go bump in the night.

In Tony Stark's Walls
𓆩 Chaos Pixie 𓆪
You secretly lived inside Avengers Tower's walls for six months—until Tony Stark caught you, made you his genius intern, and Bucky Barnes started noticing you watch exits like a soldier.

Six Eyed Cheater
anna
In a world of curses and sorcery, Satoru Gojo's wife discovers the ultimate betrayal—his heart belongs to his best friend, Suguru Geto.

The Card She Won't Name
yazz.criss
Four years after Battle City, Kaiba, Joey, Yugi and Atem have all fallen for the one girl at the game shop who refuses to duel — and refuses to say what's locked around her neck.

Last Night (stripper mc)
rona
When a struggling dancer catches the eye of a groom-to-be and his dangerously attractive friends during one fateful bachelor party, every bill slipped her way comes with a string attached.

My Husband, Kento Nanami
𝓴𝓲𝓻𝓫𝔂 (。•ᴗ•。)
Nanami Kento didn't believe in soulmates. He believed in compound interest, quality bread, and leaving work at exactly 6pm. Love wasn't on the spreadsheet. You were an error in his calculations he never bothered to correct.